BOOK REVIEW: They All Had A Reason by Michelle Leathers

Rating

Title: They All Had A Reason
Author: Michelle Leathers
Publication: October 7, 2025
Publisher: Sourcebooks Fire
Genre: Teen, YA Fiction, Horror
Pages: 224

Amazon | Barnes and Noble | Goodreads | Author Website

SYNOPSIS: (From Goodreads)

A rumor. A secret. A lie. A murder.

Charlotte is convinced that popular, pretentious Bellany Silverfield is out to get her. But it turns out somebody is―or was―out to get Bellany: Charlotte finds her high-school bully dead in the woods, having been brutally murdered. While Charlotte is desperate to find the killer, she would be lying to herself if she wasn’t a little relieved that Bellany was finally done tormenting Charlotte and her friends.

But circumstantial evidence and rumors start circling around town, funneling suspicion towards Charlotte herself. Good thing Charlotte has her friends to support her…right?

As loyalties shift and friendships are tested, it looks like Bellany has one last cruel prank to play that will leave Charlotte behind bars…or worse.

REVIEW:

**A copy of this book was provided by the publisher via NetGalley in exchange for an honest review.**

I am always up for a good YA mystery, especially one involving secrets, murder, and a group of people who may not be telling the truth! They All Had a Reason by Michele Leathers follows Charlotte, a teenager whose life gets turned upside down when Bellany Silverfield, the popular girl who has made her life miserable, is found murdered. Unfortunately for Charlotte, she quickly becomes a suspect, and suddenly she has to figure out who really killed Bellany before she ends up taking the blame. The premise definitely caught my attention, and I liked that this was a relatively short book. Sometimes it’s nice to pick up a mystery that doesn’t require 400 pages to tell the story!

Unfortunately, this one just didn’t grab me the way I had hoped. In fact, for such a short book, it took me a surprisingly long time to finish! And I think that says quite a bit about my experience. I love a mystery that makes me want to keep reading just one more chapter, but I never really felt that pull with this one. The story had potential, but I think it could have benefited from a little more character development and a stronger connection between the reader and the people involved. Some of the situations also felt a little unrealistic, and the writing seemed geared toward a younger audience than I typically prefer, even when reading YA fiction. I don’t mind teenage drama in a young adult book, but I still want the characters and their decisions to feel believable. Ultimately, I just wasn’t particularly invested in what was happening, which made it difficult to get through despite the shorter length.

With that being said, I do think there is an audience for this book! The premise is interesting, there are plenty of secrets and suspicious characters, and the mystery gives readers several possible suspects to consider. I can see younger YA readers enjoying the drama and trying to figure out who is responsible. For me, though, this was a pretty average three-star read. It wasn’t terrible, but it wasn’t particularly memorable either. I finished it, I appreciated the concept, and then I moved on. Not every book is going to be a favorite, and that’s okay! If you enjoy shorter YA murder mysteries with plenty of secrets and teenage drama, I would still encourage you to give They All Had a Reason a try and decide for yourself!

Leave a Reply